N-Gage Fix in the Works, Excuse for the Problem: Piracy
Thanks to this blog, I have been able to develop great relationships with countless mobile developers over the past year and a half. Anyone who knows me knows that I am extremely pro-developer; Symbian developers are, after all, the very thing that makes S60 such a terrific platform.
An issue came up this past Wednesday that you’ve all read about already. I dubbed it “N-Gagegate” over on BGR but it really isn’t a laughing matter. On the one hand, it’s a stunning testament to just how responsive Nokia can be in some situations. Two sentence recap: It was discovered that N-Gage games were locked to a device IMEI so if the purchaser acquires a new handset, all games are lost forever. Two days later, a solution was announced to be in the works. Awesome job Nokia - users (and press) spoke, you listened.
I did want to comment on James’ post from Nokia Conversations however. Here’s a quote:
As it stands, you can transfer your profile and associated info, but due to piracy issues, not the games.
I’m not shooting the messenger here but Nokia, this is not only a bad excuse, it’s a terrible one. Rookie, even. Rule number 1: Don’t damage your relationship with paying customers in order to prevent “non-paying customers”. Never. There is no question that this issue came up many times during the N-Gage development process; if we tie games to the IMEI, piracy will be made more difficult but users will be pissed! The fact that the N-Gage product was ever released in this fashion is inexcusable in my opinion.
As I’ve discussed with many developers, 95% of “pirates” would not have paid to use your application even if a pirated option was not available. To be honest, I’ve yet to find a developer who would disagree with that statement. Developers need to focus on potential business, not a bunch of children with no money who are using pirated copies of their software. Yes, of course you should implement a certain level of security - no need to tempt real customers over to the dark side. To take the route that Nokia did with N-Gage though and attempt to make games disposable is a joke. But…
The interesting thing now is that this will be a change for mobile gaming. More often than not, games and apps are tied to a specific device and can’t be transferred to a new one.
No. Not good enough. Nokia is supposed to revolutionize! Furthermore, the system itself dictates game portability. Let’s not get crazy here. Thankfully, James goes on to say:
As N-Gage games are tied to a profile and a device, it’s more realistic to be able to port them. That said, it isn’t without it’s challenges, but thankfully those are being figured out. Finally.
In the end, I’m glad that Nokia found a solution to the problem [that they should have never created]. Response time was fantastic, so kudos for that. Project Management should have thought this one through a bit better though because we all know how news is - 75% of the sites who posted “the bad news” won’t post this “good news”. Rightfully so, perhaps, if a lesson is learned.
Add New Comment
Viewing 7 Comments
Thanks. Your comment is awaiting approval by a moderator.
Do you already have an account? Log in and claim this comment.
Do you already have an account? Log in and claim this comment.
I think to be fair to Nokia they have a point about transfer on other mobile games. But ultimately you're right - and just because others do it...
Piracy is an interesting issue, there clearly is a bit of problem in some areas as a number of developers have commented. Personally I think you need enough protection to put off the casual person (e.g. some kind of code), but the more barriers you add (e.g. IMEI locking, online registration) the more you annoy legitimate users. I guess its a balance.
Do you already have an account? Log in and claim this comment.
An example of what I view to be an excellent compromise is DRM Commons Solutions. It has good security functionality but it also gives the user many benefits, ie no need to re-input a license code when you reinstall the app after flashing, the ability to check for updates, etc. The initial N-Gage is almost a polar opposite. Extreme security along with an incredible burden.
Do you already have an account? Log in and claim this comment.
Do you already have an account? Log in and claim this comment.
Do you already have an account? Log in and claim this comment.
Do you already have an account? Log in and claim this comment.
Do you already have an account? Log in and claim this comment.
nursing humor
Add New Comment